
Rich Johnston recently revealed how much a penciler starting out at Marvel and/or DC Comics would make, figuring an artist penciling a full monthly book could make over $38K a year, plus sales from selling original art as well as commissions from fans.
What he doesn’t state or talk about is the fact Marvel and DC represent the pinnacle of page rates for creators, ignoring the fact most creators make less – far less in most cases – working for other publishers.
I speak from experience with a 40-year perspective of having worked in the business that pay for producing script and art in the comic book industry really hasn’t changed much during that time. If anything, it’s gotten worse.
When I received my 1st professional comic book assignment, it was as a penciler for the DC Comics mini-series WHO’S WHO IN STAR TREK issue 1. It was for 6 pages of penciled illustrations and I was paid $75 a page. By the time I illustrated the pencil art for CAPTAIN ATOM issue 41, my page rate for pencils was $150. By the mid-1990s, I was earning $200 per page penciling an issue for Malibu Comics’ STAR TREK DEEP SPACE NINE series. I produced 3 issues worth of material.
When I was being considered for the gig of full-time penciler on a series DC Comics was considering licensing from LucasArts, I was paid $250 a page for 3 pages of penciled & inked character sketches along with $150 per page for 3 pages of sample storytelling displaying the characters. I was told if the series was a go, I would be offered a contract committing me to 24 issues – the length of the license – along with the cover assignment for the book starting with issue 13.
Had the assignment moved forward, I most certainly would not have had time to even submit sample pitches to Archie Comics for their SONIC THE HEDGEHOG series. But due to various factors beyond my or even DC Comics’ control, the project collapsed.
During this time, I landed my 1st writing assignment for DC Comics. I don’t remember what it paid, but I know it was more than $50 for a page of script. When I submitted my 1st sample story pitches to Archie Comics for the SONIC series, it was all on spec with no guarantee of acceptance or payment.
My partner Mike Kanterovich and I won approval to develop 2 of the 3 pitches submitted into scripts, which we were then told we had to submit in page-panel format. That meant submitting a rough layout of each page showing the placement of the characters and word balloons. As Mike didn’t draw, I created the final look of our scripts. We were paid $40 per page of script which we split down the middle, but I was never paid for my layouts, which whatever penciler was assigned would use as their template when drawing the pages.
It was within a year or two after submitting our first scripts that Archie increased the page rate for scripts to $45. When I penciled a story I wrote, I received $85 per page. For inks, it was $75 a page. Lettering was $25 a page with coloring $20 a page back then. The difference between then and now with regards to coloring and lettering is that both are now generally done on a computer whereas both back then were done by hand. Coloring was generally applying markers or colored dyes to xerox copies then assigning an alpha-numeric code to specify which color was being depicted.
I lasted so long on the SONIC series despite being pulled off the book at least twice for irritating the publishers with my stand of supporting Dan DeCarlo publicly while he sued Archie over JOSIE AND THE PUSSYCATS as well as SABRINA THE TEENAGE WITCH, was due to my track record regarding sales of the SONIC book as well as Archie’s practice of sticking with talent who adhered to their mandates, especially when it came to meeting deadlines. Slackers were not tolerated.
What Rich also didn’t mention is that a creator’s longevity on any given book can never be taken for granted, as an editor who’s taken off a book and replaced with another editor generally means the writer and artists on the book are generally replaced as well.
I kept the wheels running on the SONIC and KNUCKLES series, lasting through 4 different editor changes, until it got to the point where I was making much more doing freelance for ad agencies as well as storyboards for animation and independent film projects.
Back in 2006, I was making $2000 a week at Film Roman producing storyboards for the FOX animated series KING OF THE HILL, which made the decision to leave Archie a no-brainer. (In all honesty, another reason I stayed so long is that SONIC was always my son’s favorite book, but by the time he was about to start college, he made it easier for me to work elsewhere,)
Within another few years, once I was well into my legal battle with Archie, I was told a number of stories of what people were earning, some of which made it into the affidavits in support of my case.
For example, Archie paid less for talent on their core titles than they did on the SEGA-licensed books. Inkers received $55 to ink an Archie page, whereas they would receive $75 a page on SONIC. Part of that was due to inker Jon D’Agostino’s complaining how much extra work SONIC required as opposed to the Archie assignments. Jon had been working for the company for so long and the company was reluctant to deal with any newcomers at the time.
While both Dan DeCarlo and Stan Goldberg received the highest page rates at the time from the company – $130 per page – when sales took a down turn, Archie didn’t hesitate to cut both men’s page rates by $20 per page, despite their long association with the company.
Rich also didn’t talk about how artists are exploited when it comes to reprints or other reuse of the artists’ work. Neither Archie or IDW has ever paid royalties for reprints, nor has any company releasing reprint collections of various series such DOCTOR SOLAR or other titles originally published under the Gold Key banner or any other company.
Go talk to artists who worked on various STAR TREK titles prior to IDW obtaining the license. Arne Starr, Gordon Purcell, myself and others all signed work-for-hire agreements that stipulated in exchange for our transfer of rights, we’d be paid for any reprinting of out work. When approached about paying royalties for work originally contracted for by DC Comics, IDW would tell freelancers to talk to Paramount or DC. When freelancers contacted Paramount, the licensing department would tell freelancers to talk to DC. When talking to DC, their representative would say DC no longer publishes the book, hasn’t had the license in a long time and suggests the freelancer talk to Paramount.
And STAR TREK is not the only licensed title freelancers are getting screwed out of what’s due them.
IDW has a history of reprinting a lot of work in which they never paid royalties to any of the freelancers whose work was used, even when the artists’ work was the main focus of the book. Stan Goldberg bitterly complained how IDW released a book titled THE BEST OF STAN GOLDBERG, yet he didn’t receive a dime from the sales nor did the company send him any complimentary copies of the published book as even a minimum form of compensation.
I myself was never contacted when Marvel reprinted a story I inked that was featured in the KULL OMNIBUS, nor was I contacted by Eaglemoss regarding the reprinting of my Trek work. It was only when one of the editors reached out to me regarding my unpublished Trek projects intended for DC and Marvel that I was able to least obtain a set of the books that featured my work. IDW never saw fit to contact me regarding the work I did for the TSR licensed books that DC Comics originally published that they were now collecting in trade paperback format. Nor has DC Comics reached out in any way as a result of my work being included in their WHO’S WHO IN DC COMICS OMNIBUS.
And I’m far from the only one receiving such treatment.
Rich also goes on to talk about how artists can make money on commissions or selling their artwork. And indeed they can. But not every page is a gem, nor is coherent storytelling a given, as more artists design their pages to feature the characters in the most active poses sellable to their audience. If a penciler’s work is sharp and clear with varying line weights, what do they need an inker for? If a penciler sends in only the scans of his pages, he or she gets to keep the all the actual art as all the inker is left with is digital reproductions.
One of the aspects that influenced me way back when on getting into comics wasn’t just the fun of writing and drawing stories, but the practicality of actually earning a living doing so. Take a look at pictures of people who worked for Marvel back in the late 1960’s. They wore jackets, dress shirts and ties, looking like they worked alongside Don Draper in MAD MEN. Many had families, owned homes and cars, enjoyed a night out. It was a steady gig for most, or so it seemed.
Before the Image guys left Marvel to form their own company, a number of freelancers were paid royalties that enabled them to put a substantial down payment on a home. I don’t hear of anyone able to do that these days unless the money comes in the form of payments from film or television projects.
One question that keeps getting asked these days is why would established Hollywood talent even bother slumming it for the low pay in comics? The answer is lies in comics being a cheap form of research & development, enabling an established talent to sell his or her own property as a film or TV project based on the property’s track record as a series or graphic novel. The secondary reason is that a creator in comics receives generally more recognition for their contribution to the work than they would in most cases from a TV or film project. With film, the directors generally get the lion’s share of the credit. Once more than one name is listed for the screenwriting credits, it’s hard to figure out who did what, thus the recognition doesn’t follow. Likewise, in television, it’s the series creator that receives the most credit. Other writers have worked on episodes throughout the run of MAD MEN, but it’s Matthew Weiner who gets the credit, as do other creators similar receive from the series they spearheaded.
With comics, especially creator-owned books, there’s no debating who did what. Even if a writer didn’t create the book, comic book writers are generally afforded more credit than most, thus you have Chris Claremont’s X-MEN, or Alan Moore’s SWAMP THING. Or even me with SONIC. While I have always maintained I never created Sonic and/or Knuckles, that doesn’t stop people from thinking I have.
Frankly, for the amount of work it takes to produce a monthly comic book, $3200 a month or $38,400 annually is not a living wage, especially in most places in the United States, let alone New York and Los Angeles. After taxes and rent (forget about a mortgage), there’s groceries (at a minimum people are spending $100 a week to eat and we’re not talking filet mignon either), transportation (owning or leasing a car requires fuel and insurance), utilities and so on. Before one can even subscribe to a streaming service, one has to pay for monthly internet service, which can cost $50 to $100 or more a month. We haven’t even talked entertainment or more serious matters like settling down and having kids.
One can earn a better living working at McDonald’s or Staples. Costco is now paying $30 an hour minimum wage to its workers. At the company my next door neighbor owns, not one of his workers makes less than $20 an hour, and they all have benefits including health care and paid tuition assistance.
To really put the $38,400 in true perspective, writer George Gladir was earning that much annually writing scripts for various Archie comics back in 1996. He had been working for the company for over 30 years by that point and was cranking out the pages to earn that amount. It’s now 30 years later and to call $38, 400 decent pay for the work involved, especially penciling and inking, is an insult. My son works in video production and makes six figures while essentially working 9 to 5 Monday through Friday. That’s what your typical penciler and inker should be earning, especially those working for Marvel and/or DC Comics when one considers how many times the work will repackaged or repurposed.
As for me, I’m doing my part to help out my fellow creators.

I’m collecting the stories I worked on and publishing them myself. I’m also paying advance royalties to other writers and artists who worked on these books. I’ve a set formula where I can tell the freelancer what they’ll make based on sales. To date, before my books are even published, I’ve paid out more in royalties to my fellow creators than IDW and Archie have paid out combined. (Of course, it’s easy to say that when neither company pays anything in royalties, period.)
I’m releasing the KEN PENDERS’ KNUCKLES OMNIBUS VOLUME ONE solely through my own website. There is no going through Diamond, Lunar, Amazon or any other distributor. I’m dependent solely on pre-orders to get the books printed and released to the public, and once released, the sales take off from there, especially when people see the effort and quality put into each book.
I also don’t do Kickstarter, GoFundMe or Patreon. So if anyone reading this believes in supporting creators, any purchase of the Mobian Adventure Line will not only be appreciated by myself, but also by the other creators involved. If that’s a shameless plug, so be it.
Creators need to begin thinking of alternatives because the current system just isn’t working for the majority. If I can treat my fellow creators as they deserve, why can’t other publishers as well?
With the fate of Diamond Distribution up in the air, creators need to think long and hard about the best path for their future and building an audience.